I have a soft spot for the woman who texts first. She liked somebody. She’d like to see him on Thursday. What I find strange is how easily a perfectly good Thursday can disappear into a debate about whether asking for it makes her look cheap.

That’s the part of dark femininity I want to talk about. I understand the appeal of being the woman who can walk away. What troubles me is the advice about how beautiful you’re supposed to look from behind, and how badly he’s supposed to want you back. I’d like to know where you were going. Maybe there was somewhere you genuinely wanted to be.

What does dark femininity ask of women?

Dark femininity means different things depending on whose account you’ve landed on. You might find a woman trying a deep plum lipstick, somebody talking about the anger she’s finally allowed herself to feel, or a dating coach explaining how to keep a man guessing. I’m interested in the third one. In her reporting for Le Monde, Romane Lizée describes tutorials so precise that a woman can learn which of a man’s eyes to look at before dropping her gaze to his lips. I got stuck on one ordinary detail. How much of what he’s saying can you hear while you’re trying to remember which eye comes next?

For a closer look at what one influential account actually teaches, I turned to researchers Meaghan Furlano and Emma Cowley. They read 1,946 Instagram posts from one dark femininity influencer. In those posts, women were offered a route to love and money through a fairly strict idea of how women and men should behave. What I take from the study is how many instructions can come bundled with the promise of freedom. The researchers looked at what one account published. A woman saving one of those posts might take a single idea she likes and ignore everything else.

I can see why “let him chase” sounds good

If you’ve picked the restaurant three Saturdays in a row, checked the menu because he’s fussy, and found parking near his place because he hates driving downtown, “let him chase” probably sounds like a night off. I’d be reluctant to talk anyone out of that. There’s a particular kind of loneliness in going on dates that only happen because you do all the work of getting two people into the same room.

Where I’d pause is the morning after you decide to stop. Perhaps you wake up relieved that Saturday is yours again. Or perhaps you wake up wondering how long it usually takes a man to notice his Saturday has stopped arranging itself. Both reactions make sense. The second one tells you there’s still something you want from him. I think it’s kinder to admit that wish than to spend the weekend trying to pass an imaginary test of how little you care.

You might even want something quite modest. You’d like him to ring a restaurant. You’d like to arrive somewhere and have him say, “I got us the table by the window.” Once you put it that plainly, you can decide whether to ask for it, give him a turn, or spend Saturday with someone whose idea of sharing an evening already includes sharing the work.

The words I’d change in dark femininity advice

When a piece of dating advice sounds especially good, I like to finish the sentence. “Be unforgettable” becomes “Be unforgettable to a man I’ve met twice.” Suddenly I have questions about the amount of work involved and whether I even remember his last name. Here are a few more examples in my own words.

dark femininity dating advice

The last one matters to me. Listening closely is one of the nicest parts of liking someone. It would be a shame to spend a whole date rationing something you enjoy giving, only to go home with a man who has learned precisely how much effort it takes to keep you talking and very little about what you like talking about.

Yes, playing hard to get can work. What have you won?

I don’t think an honest answer can dismiss the chase as a myth. In three studies, Gurit Birnbaum and colleagues looked at what happens when somebody seems selective or hard to attract. People who saw a potential partner that way could see them as more desirable and make more effort to meet again. The researchers studied early attraction. They didn’t follow these pairs through six months of missed trains, family birthdays and arguments about whose turn it was to buy groceries.

What I find useful here is the modest size of the question the researchers could answer. If what you want is a second invitation, a second invitation is a lovely result. If what you want is a man who can hear “that hurt my feelings” without making the next hour about your tone, you’ll need to learn something else about him. It’s easy to lose sight of that when a phone lights up and the message you’ve wanted all day is finally there.

what his dating gestures tell you

How did his bad manners become her homework?

Suppose a man cancels dinner twenty minutes before you’re due to meet. You’ve already paid for the bus. Your first thought might reasonably be that you’re hungry. Yet it’s easy to imagine the next hour going into a discussion of whether you answered too quickly when he first asked you out. I’d bring the bus fare back into the conversation. Somebody had enough information to send a message earlier, and somebody else is standing outside a restaurant.

In Confidence Culture, Shani Orgad and Rosalind Gill examine the pressure on women to work on themselves when the difficulty they’re facing has roots beyond them. Their argument helped me put a finger on what bothers me about that canceled dinner. Once the discussion turns to how confidently the woman handled it, the man who left her waiting has very little to answer for. She could have the highest opinion of herself in the world and she’d still need to get home.

If this were a friend telling me about her evening, I hope my first question would be whether she’d eaten. Later I might ask what happened when she told him she was annoyed. Did he apologize? Did he explain and offer to come to her side of town next time? There’s room for a perfectly decent person to make a mess of an evening. There should also be room for the woman who got the bus to say it was a pain.

The freedom to be a little embarrassing

My least favorite rule is the one that makes enthusiasm look like a rookie mistake. You’ve met someone else who loves the obscure detective show your friends refuse to watch. You want to tell him your theory about the missing suitcase. Somewhere between opening your mouth and getting to the good bit, you remember you’re meant to leave a little mystery. Now two people who might have had a very funny disagreement are talking about work again.

There’s a real risk in letting somebody see what delights you. He might look blank. He might say he stopped watching after episode two, which would be disappointing for several reasons. But if I were choosing a person to share a sofa with for the next few years, I’d want to know how it feels to be a little ridiculous beside him. A date can go beautifully according to plan and give you almost no information about that.

When you get home, try finishing this thought before you check your phone. I wish we’d had more time to talk about… → Would I actually like another evening with him? The answer might surprise you. You can be thrilled that somebody likes you and slightly relieved when you never have to sit through another one of his stories.

What I’d keep, and what I’d say out loud

I’d keep the privacy. There are things a man you met last Tuesday has no particular claim to know. I’d keep the right to go home early, wear the dress, skip the dress, take a compliment and enjoy being desired. I’d also keep the option to change your mind halfway through an evening without turning it into a statement about the kind of woman you are.

The words I’d borrow for real life tend to be much less impressive than anything you could put over a slow motion video. That’s one reason I like them. You can say them in a noisy bar while looking for your coat.

what to say on a date when you know what you mean

I’d still send the Thursday text

What I want for the woman with Thursday free is pretty ordinary. I want her to be able to ask somebody out and feel a bit nervous until he answers. I want her to have a friend she can ring if he says no, preferably one who won’t turn the disappointment into a lesson about letting men come to her. Sometimes you like somebody a little more than they like you. That feeling is rough enough without being told you brought it on yourself by being easy to read.

And if he says yes? Pick a place where you can actually hear each other. Bring up the detective show if you feel like it. By the end of the evening you might have an answer to a question no amount of dark femininity advice can settle in advance. When Thursday was yours to spend, did you like spending it with him?

FAQ

  1. What is dark femininity in dating?

    It’s a loose term for advice that links a woman’s romantic appeal to mystery, sensuality and being selective. I look at what a particular creator is promising. A suggestion to take your time can turn into a very different proposition once somebody promises it will make a man obsessed.

  2. Is it wrong to enjoy feeling desirable?

    Of course you can enjoy it. Having a person you fancy look up when you walk into the room is a pleasure in its own right. I’d only start asking questions if his interest became the deciding vote on whether you’d had a good evening.

  3. Does texting first make me look desperate?

    A single message tells him you wanted to send a message. If you’ve written three times, received no answer and feel miserable, you have a good reason to put the phone down. If he asked for the name of that brilliant book, send him the title whenever you remember it.

  4. How do I tell a boundary from a dating tactic?

    Try picturing the other person taking you at your word. You say you want Sunday to yourself and he wishes you a lovely Sunday. If you feel relieved, you’ve probably asked for something you needed. If you were hoping he’d insist on coming over, it’s worth getting curious about what you wanted to hear.

  5. Can I be genuinely mysterious?

    You can be private, slow to trust or simply someone with a lot going on. You don’t owe a date the full story of your divorce because the starters are taking ages. A quiet “I’d rather save that for another day” is enough.

  6. What if I like a man who takes the lead?

    That’s a preference you’re entitled to. I’d ask whether you also feel free to take the lead on something you care about. Liking it when he chooses a restaurant can comfortably coexist with having strong views about where to spend your birthday.

  7. Can playing hard to get lead to a good relationship?

    A good relationship can start in plenty of ways. The attraction studies discussed here looked at desire and efforts to reconnect. They give us little basis for predicting how a particular couple will treat each other later.

  8. What if I’ve been too available in the past?

    Get specific about what cost you something. Did you lose sleep, cancel on a friend or drive across town when you had an early shift? Protecting that part of your week gives you a clearer place to start than trying to become harder for everyone to reach.

  9. Does wearing a dark feminine look mean I’m performing for men?

    A dress tells me astonishingly little about who you hoped would see it. You might enjoy the shape, the reference to an old film, or the look on your girlfriend’s face. The person who put it on gets to have a say in what it means.

  10. How do I stop analyzing every message?

    With a message that sends you into a spiral, try writing down what you need to know in plain English. “Are we still meeting at seven?” is a question the other person can answer. You could spend an afternoon examining the tone of “sounds good” and still have no idea whether to leave the house.

  11. What can I ask a friend after her date?

    I like “What was he like when you disagreed?” and “Which part would you happily do again?” Both leave room for an interesting answer. And if she wants to tell you about the dessert for ten minutes, perhaps that tells you something about the date as well.

Sources and inspirations

Leave a Reply

Trending

Discover more from careandselflove

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading